Your mileage may vary…
Paul at Uber Affiliate shared a tip with me about GeoTargeting at Ad:tech and then blogged about it today.
We had tested this in the past and our results were that our CTR went down significantly and our CR also declined slightly. One thought for the change, is that we are selling national products that people probably do not think of as state specific. I was more profitable even with the non-targeted out of zone clicks (which was less than 5% of total click volume) so since my primary goal is total profit, I preferred to do without the Geo-Targeting.
A second thing is that Google’s geo-targeting is screwy. For a long time our search results at the office thought we were in a city and state more than 1000 miles from our actual location. I have spoken with other industry Pro’s who also have similar problems. Also dont forget about the school district that sued Google because it showed ads for another country. I don’t exactly get a warm fuzzy when an advertisers tells me I can get a great deal 4 states away - their credibility (courtesy of Google) is shot from the start.
I think Paul’s idea of testing this is very valid and will probably work for some verticals. The problem is that lots of people will just read and implement without testing. Anything you read on my blog or any other should be taken with a grain of salt and only implemented if it makes sense for your business, as well as actually performs better than what you have now. The only way you will figure it out is by testing.
